Both speakers work, but the cones need to be replaced. You’re buying these as is no returns. The Vintage Sansui S-57 3-Way 3 Speaker System Set is a classic audio setup that delivers high-quality sound with a retro vibe. With the trusted Sansui brand name and unique S-57 model, this speaker system is sure to bring a touch of nostalgia to any vintage audio setup. Perfect for music lovers looking to add a vintage flair to their home entertainment system.